Email guide

Email forwarding, mailbox, alias or catch-all?

Four words come up the moment you put email on your own domain. They sound alike and do different jobs, and picking the wrong one is why replies end up coming from your old Gmail address.

Short answer

  • A mailbox stores mail and sends as your address.
  • Forwarding only passes incoming mail to another inbox, so your replies leave from that other address unless you set up sending separately.
  • An alias is an extra address that delivers into a mailbox you already have.
  • A catch-all delivers mail for every address at your domain into one inbox.
  • A one-person brand wants one real mailbox with a catch-all or a few aliases on it.

The four, side by side

Receives mailStores mailSends as your domainUsual cost
MailboxYesYesYesPaid, per mailbox
ForwardingYes, then passes it onNoNot by itselfOften free with a domain
AliasYes, into an existing mailboxIn that mailboxUsually, from that mailboxUsually free with a mailbox
Catch-allYes, for any address at the domainIn one mailboxDepends on the serviceUsually free with a mailbox
Forwarding, mailbox or alias?: a consultant's personal website made with Bounley on a laptop at its own domain, yourname.com, beside a mailbox at you@yourname.com and the email aliases bookings@ and press@ that arrive in it.
Forwarding, mailbox or alias? · Bounley

A mailbox: the real thing

A mailbox is an inbox that belongs to your address. Mail to you@yourname.com arrives there, stays there, and your replies leave from you@yourname.com, signed by your domain. It is what people mean by “email at your own domain”, and it is the only one of the four that does the whole job without help.

Email hosts generally charge per mailbox each month. One is enough for one person: you don’t need a second mailbox to have a second address.

Forwarding: cheap, and where it goes wrong

Forwarding takes mail sent to you@yourname.com and passes it to an inbox you already have, such as a Gmail account. Many domain registrars include it free, which is why it’s the first thing most people try.

  • Your replies give you away. You read the message in Gmail, so your reply leaves from yourname2003@gmail.com. The brand that wrote to your professional address gets an answer from your personal one.
  • “Send as” is the usual patch, and it’s being withdrawn. Gmail lets you send as another address through that address’s own server. Google’s help pages say this ends in January 2027 for addresses Google doesn’t host. What works with Gmail in 2026 and 2027.
  • Forwarded mail is filtered more. When a message is passed on, the checks that prove where it came from (SPF in particular) can fail at the second inbox, so some forwarded mail lands in spam or is refused.
  • Nothing is stored at your domain. If the Gmail account is lost, so is the mail.

Forwarding is fine for an address you only receive on: a receipts@ or a domains@ you never reply from.

An alias: a second name for the same inbox

An alias is another address that delivers into a mailbox you already have. bookings@yourname.com and press@yourname.com can both be aliases of you@yourname.com: three addresses, one inbox, one bill.

Use aliases to sort mail by what it’s about, not to look bigger than you are. contact@, hello@ or info@ covers which ones a personal brand needs.

A catch-all: every address works

A catch-all delivers mail for any address at your domain, including ones you never set up, into one inbox. If a venue writes to booking@ when your address is bookings@, it still arrives.

  • For: no missed mail from a mistyped or guessed address, and you can give a different address to each sign-up (shop@, newsletter@) to see who passes it on.
  • Against: spam sent to made-up addresses at your domain arrives too, so the inbox needs a decent filter.

Which a one-person brand needs

  • One real mailbox, at the address you’ll put in your bios and signature.
  • A catch-all, or two or three aliases, so bookings@ and press@ reach the same inbox.
  • Replies that leave from the address the person wrote to.
  • No forwarding into a personal account for anything you answer.

How Bounley does it

Bounley Premium gives your domain one inbox, inside Bounley next to your site. You start as contact@yourname.com and can change it. Mail to every address at your domain lands in that inbox, and a reply goes out from the address the message was sent to, with your signature under it. There’s nothing to forward and no “send as” to set up. Premium is invitation-only during the beta: join the waitlist and we’ll email you the day it opens.

Email forwarding against a real mailbox at your own domain: “Forwarding to Gmail” crossed out beside you@yourname.com, and a phone showing a real Bounley email thread with a reply being written from you@yourname.com.
A real mailbox at your own domain. Made with Bounley.
Email aliases and a catch-all at your own domain with Bounley: you@yourname.com, bookings@yourname.com and anything@yourname.com written large, all arriving in one inbox, beside a phone showing the real Bounley inbox with sample messages.
Every address at your domain, one inbox. Made with Bounley.

Questions

Is email forwarding enough for a business?

Only for addresses you never reply from. The moment you answer, the reply leaves from the inbox the mail was forwarded to, which is usually a personal address.

What is the difference between an alias and forwarding?

An alias delivers into a mailbox at the same email service, so you can usually send as it too. Forwarding hands the message to a different service, which can’t send as your domain without extra set-up.

Does a catch-all get more spam?

It can, because mail to addresses that don’t exist is accepted instead of bounced. A good spam filter deals with most of it, and you can turn the catch-all off and keep named aliases if it becomes a nuisance.

How many mailboxes does one person need?

One. Extra addresses should be aliases of it, so you read everything in one place and pay for one mailbox.

Keep reading